Researchers put two electrodes in a pool that a dolphin swam in. When the dolphin swam near the electrodes, the researchers would sometimes create a weak electric field by activating the electrodes. The dolphin would swim away if the electrodes were activated; otherwise it acted normally. The researchers then placed a plastic shield over small organs called vibrissal crypts located on the dolphin’s snout. With the crypts covered, the dolphin no longer swam away when the electrodes were activated.

Summary
Researchers placed electrodes in a pool with a dolphin. When activated, the electrodes created a weak electric field, causing the dolphin to swim away. When they were not activated, the dolphin behaved normally. After covering the dolphin's vibrissal crypts with a plastic shield, the dolphin no longer swam away when the electrodes were activated.

Strongly Supported Conclusions
The vibrissal crypts impact a dolphin’s ability to detect electric fields.
Dolphins instinctively swim from electrical fields

A
In the wild, dolphins sometimes encounter strong electric fields.
There is no information about this in the stimulus. You have to assume that because they have vibrissal crypts, there are strong electric fields in the wild.
B
Vibrissal crypts enable dolphins to sense electric fields.
The experiment showed that the dolphin no longer reacted to the electrical field when the vibrissal crypts were covered. It is reasonable assume that the crypts impact the dolphin’s ability to sense electric fields.
C
Dolphins do not instinctually avoid electric fields, but they can be trained to do so.
This is antisupported. The study showed how the dolphins instinctively avoided the electric fields when they were present.
D
Electric fields interfere with the normal functioning of dolphins’ vibrissal crypts.
This is antisupported. The plastic shields interfere with the normal functioning of vibrissal crypts. That’s why the dolphin no longer avoided the electrical field.
E
Under normal circumstances, dolphins are unable to sense electric fields.
This is antisupported. Dolphins are normally able to sense electric fields. It is only when their vibrissal crypts are covered that it no longer detected them.

7 comments

Insurers and doctors are well aware that the incidence of lower-back injuries among office workers who spend long hours sitting is higher than that among people who regularly do physical work of a type known to place heavy stresses on the lower back. This shows that office equipment and furniture are not properly designed to promote workers’ health.

Summarize Argument: Phenomenon-Hypothesis
The author hypothesizes that office equipment and furniture are not properly designed to promote workers’ health. This is based on the fact that the incidence of lower-back injuries among office workers who spend a long time sitting is higher than the incidence of lower-back injuries among people who regularly do physical work that puts stresses on their lower back.

Notable Assumptions
The author assumes that the there’s no other explanation for the higher rate of lower-back injuries among office workers than the design of office equipment and furniture. This overlooks the possibility that there’s some difference between office workers and physical laborers that might account the difference in rate of lower-back injury.

A
When they are at home, laborers and office workers tend to spend similar amounts of time sitting.
If anything, this strengthens the argument by eliminating differences in sitting time at home as a potential explanation. For example, if officer workers had sit a lot more at home, then the overall sitting time might have been the true explanation for the higher rate of injury.
B
Insurance companies tend to dislike selling policies to companies whose workers often claim to have back pain.
What insurance companies prefer has no impact on what might explain the disparity in lower-back injury between office workers and physical laborers.
C
People who regularly do physical work of a type known to place heavy stress on the lower back are encouraged to use techniques that reduce the degree of stress involved.
We have no reason to think office workers aren’t similarly encouraged to use techniques that reduce back stress (ex. seat cushions). In addition, even if the laborers can reduce back stress, we’d still expect them to get back injuries at a higher rate than office workers.
D
Most of the lower-back injuries that office workers suffer occur while they are on the job.
The timing of injuries doesn’t have clear impact on the argument. Back stress might cause injury at work or it might build up and lead to injury at home. If this answer does anything, it might strengthen the argument by connecting injuries to the office.
E
Consistent physical exercise is one of the most effective ways to prevent or recover from lower-back injuries.
Laborers get much more physical exercise (which includes more than just gym activities/cardio) than office workers on the job. This disparity in physical exercise, rather than office equipment design, could be the true explanation for the disparity in lower-back injuries.

100 comments

An analysis of the language in social media messages posted via the Internet determined that, on average, the use of words associated with positive moods is common in the morning, decreases gradually to a low point midafternoon, and then increases sharply throughout the evening. This shows that a person’s mood typically starts out happy in the morning, declines during the day, and improves in the evening.

Summarize Argument: Phenomenon-Hypothesis

The author hypothesizes that a person’s mood usually starts out happy in the morning, drops during the day, and improves in the evening. He supports this by citing a study of the language used on social media, which found that words linked to positive moods are common in the morning, decrease in the afternoon, and rise again in the evening.

Identify and Describe Flaw

The author makes two main assumptions. First, he assumes that social media language accurately reflects a person's mood. But someone could be unhappy in the morning and still post a happy message, or vice versa.

Second, he assumes that the analysis followed the same individuals throughout the day. If people who post in the morning are different from those who post in the afternoon or evening, he can't conclude that a person's mood follows the same pattern as the language used on social media.

A
people’s overall moods are lowest at the beginning of the workweek and rise later, peaking on the weekend

The author’s argument and the analysis that he cites are both only about a person’s mood throughout a single day. The pattern of people’s moods throughout the whole week is irrelevant.

B
many people who post social media messages use neither words associated with positive moods nor words associated with negative moods

The author’s evidence only looks at those people who do use words associated with positive or negative moods on social media. The fact that many people don’t use these words is irrelevant.

C
the frequency in the use of words in social media is not necessarily indicative of the frequency of the use of those words in other forms of communication

The use of mood words in other forms of communication is irrelevant; the author only addresses language on social media. He does overlook the possibility that social media language isn’t necessarily indicative of people’s actual moods, but this is not what (C) points out.

D
the number of social media messages posted in the morning is not significantly different from the number posted in the evening

The author doesn’t overlook this possibility. He’s focused on the frequency of positive mood words used in social media messages, not the number of messages posted at different times of the day.

E
most of the social media messages posted in the evening are posted by people who rarely post such messages in the morning

If most evening messages are posted by different people than the morning messages, the author can't conclude that a person's mood follows the same pattern as the messages. The messages came from different people— this tells us nothing about one person’s mood throughout the day.


23 comments

forage
Verb. 1. (of a person or animal) search widely for food or provisions.
"gulls are equipped by nature to forage for food"
source


2 comments